The Kestrel Minority

BadJawa wrote:I'm pretty sure we can find an Imperial guild that would happily allow an exchange; we take their Republic alts, in exchange for them taking our Imperial alts. That way, we both work to improve game for each other, rather than lessening our game. That way both groups get to play their naughty alts in a good community, rather than a good community lessened.

BadJawa wrote:Wotcha everyone,

Whilst I can understand the desire to play alts, and I can understand the desire to play Imperial alts, I would urge caution when considering setting up a sister guild of our own.

What makes a good guild is a good community. It's the companionship; whether joining fellow players for questing, for instancing, or even just chatting, having other people around makes us want to play more.

And having a good community here, it's only reasonable to want to play with the same community when it's time to pull out that Imperial alt and have a blast being naughty.

Here is where I advise caution, and for a number of reasons.

Regardless of how many people join this guild, each player only gets to log on once. So they're either going to be logged on as Republic or Imperial. Not both. That means that we're lowering the number of fellow players that we'll be able to game with at any one time. And not only that, we're actively promoting less opportunity to game with each other.

We're a Republic guild. Let's try and concentrate on being the best damn Republic guild in the game. There are plenty of multi-game, multi-faction guilds out there. And I specifically chose this guild because I didn't want the community I joined to be devolve into mediocrity by trying to spread itself too thin.

Why set up an Imperial guild of our own, when we can join someone else's? I'm pretty sure we can find an Imperial guild that would happily allow an exchange; we take their Republic alts, in exchange for them taking our Imperial alts. That way, we both work to improve game for each other, rather than lessening our game. That way both groups get to play their naughty alts in a good community, rather than a good community lessened.

Now, I might have got references to "sister guild" wrong. If so, please forgive me, but if that is what's being suggested here, I would strongly and whole-heartedly recommend against it. I'm fully intending to have Imperial alts at some time, but my plan was to either solo them, or find a guild that didn't mind having an extremely part time member.

Cheers,
Hawley.

• Another Guild Pros:
• Lively guild chat
• Opportunity for grouping
• Good for people that really want to play their alts
• Crafting is better
• Meeting new peoples

• Another Guild Cons
• In the case of alts exchange, we don't have any "quality" control
• If we exchange with a big guild, we would have a lot low playing alts
• If we exchange with a small guild, might risk of guild disband or one of us end up as guild leader (happened to me twice)
• We are dependent of the guild leader's wishes, a change of GL might change the terms of our arrangement and some of us getting kicked out of the guild. What do we do on our end?

• Sister Guild Pros
• We have complete control over the guild, we don't depend on anyone
• No exchange of members without question
• Better for people that only wants to experience the other side
• We know every members of the guild

• Sister Guild Cons
• Tend to be rather dead on that side outside of "Imperial Days" we might have
• Looks much like a solo experience
• Lack of crafting opportunities

Jens Jutoon wrote:It's probably way to early to be thinking about imp alts or an imp guild anyway. I mean we haven't even played our republic characters in game yet! Like Jendoon said, it's going to be a few months after launch I would think. Any Imp alt I make will be just that, an alt. Most of my time will be dedicated to my Republic character. I just might play with the dark side every now and then, that's all.